Calender

CALENDAR

 
Donate
 
Chat
 

Court Reporters Provided for Indigent Parties in Civil Cases

By Kelly on July 12, 2018//Leave a comment

People of modest means and advocates of access to justice received some welcome news recently. On July 5, the California Supreme Court, in Jameson v. Desta, held that litigants who were entitled to fee waivers must be able to obtain a court reporter free of charge. The court found that not providing a court reporter in such situations is incompatible with both California statutes and case law on access to justice.

 

The court wrote that an official court reporter, or other valid means to create an official verbatim record for purposes of appeal, must generally be made available to in forma pauperis litigants upon request.

 

The case began when Barry Jameson, an indigent prisoner, filed a lawsuit in San Diego Superior Court accusing a prison doctor, Dr. Taddese Desta, of medical malpractice. The Superior Court dismissed the case three times and Jameson appealed each time to the Fourth Appellate District. The Appeals Court reversed and remanded each time and the case went to trial in 2014. The Superior Court had stopped providing court reporters because of budget cuts by this time.

 

The trial ended with the grant of nonsuit against Jameson. Jameson attempted to appeal, but there was no record or transcript available. The Appellate Court said that without such a record, it couldn’t reach the merits of Jameson’s argument that the trial court got it wrong. He argued the case should be reversed and remanded for a new trial that would include a court reporter, but the Court of Appeal found there was no legal error and ruled against him. Then, Jameson appealed the decision to the California Supreme Court.

There are some instances when comments will be edited or deleted. See our blog comment policy for more information.

4 Comments

  1. LYNN MCINTYRE

    THE INDIJENT CAN STILL USE A SETTLED STATEMENT?

    • Gina

      Hello, thank you for your comment on our web article.
      If you have a current case and did not pay to have a court reporter present at the lower court hearing or trial – yes you can still use a settled statement. This new change has not gone into effect yet and it will likely be a few months before the San Diego Superior Court is able to work out the details and get court reporters for fee waiver pro-pers.

  2. Darren Chaker

    Great post on Jameson v. Desta. I am happy to see it went to the California Supreme Court and I hope it sends a message to other states how indigents should the basics of equal protection. Keep up the good work San Diego Law Library!

  3. Bernadette E. Probus, CBN106208, Lead Housing Attorney, Legal Aid Society of San Diego, Inc.

    The case put things back squarely as they should be and mostly have been during my career representing indigent tenants in eviction cases over 30 years;. We’d get free copies of the tape or cd and get Transcript Fund to cover cost of transcription by certified court reporter for appeals I handled.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *